tinamarie.io
SafeSearch Not set
user icon
cart icon 0
New Arrivals/Restock
Vintage MY TOY Cat Rubber Face Plush Stuffed Animal mid-century RARE Kitty
Vintage MY TOY Cat Rubber Face Plush Stuffed Animal mid-century RARE Kitty Vintage MY TOY Cat Rubber Face Plush Stuffed Animal mid-century RARE Kitty Vintage MY TOY Cat Rubber Face Plush Stuffed Animal mid-century RARE Kitty Vintage MY TOY Cat Rubber Face Plush Stuffed Animal mid-century RARE Kitty Vintage MY TOY Cat Rubber Face Plush Stuffed Animal mid-century RARE Kitty

Vintage MY TOY Cat Rubber Face Plush Stuffed Animal mid-century RARE Kitty

flash sale iconLimited Time Sale
Until the end
01
22
31

$26.80 cheaper than the new price!!

Free shipping for purchases over $99 ( Details )
Free cash-on-delivery fees for purchases over $99
See all stores
Please note that the sales price and tax displayed may differ between online and in-store. Also, the product may be out of stock in-store.
New  $67.00
quantity

Product details

Management number 42571394 Release Date 2026/01/23 List Price $40.20 Model Number 42571394
Category
  1. Toys & Collectibles
  2. Stuffed Animals & Plush
  3. Stuffed Animals

Measures 8 1/2 inches long by about 5 inches wide by 6 1/2 inches tall.

A vintage mid-century “MY TOY” rubber face cat plush stuffed animal. This is a well loved one owner 65 years old
rubber-faced plush toys were popular in the 1950s–1960s and were manufactured by the My Toy Company, known for their whimsical designs and expressive character faces. This particular piece features a soft worn down plush body with a molded rubber face, painted features, and a charming retro design.

Condition:
• Pre-owned, good shape for its age.
• Rubber face shows surface wear, some discoloration consistent with age.
• Plush body retains much of its softness, though some areas show flattening from handling
and storage.

• No major cracks or splits noted in the rubber face.
• Please review photos carefully as they form part of the description.

Vintage MY TOY rubber face athropomorphic features kitty cat stuffed plush animal. In good shape for its age.
If found, these can sell for as much as 100.00

CategoryToys & Collectibles > Stuffed Animals & Plush > Stuffed Animals
SizeN/A
BrandNone
ConditionFair

Vintage MY TOY Cat Rubber Face Plush Stuffed Animal mid-century RARE Kitty

Vintage MY TOY Cat Rubber Face Plush Stuffed Animal mid-century RARE Kitty

Vintage MY TOY Cat Rubber Face Plush Stuffed Animal mid-century RARE Kitty

Vintage MY TOY Cat Rubber Face Plush Stuffed Animal mid-century RARE Kitty

Vintage MY TOY Cat Rubber Face Plush Stuffed Animal mid-century RARE Kitty

Vintage MY TOY Cat Rubber Face Plush Stuffed Animal mid-century RARE Kitty

Headphones

Black Holysmoke Motif On Ear Foldable Headphones

Black Holysmoke Motif On Ear Foldable Headphones

★★★★☆ (42)
$49.50
OVLENG MX666 Wireless Bluetooth Music Headphones with Mic Noise Canceling - Red

OVLENG MX666 Wireless Bluetooth Music Headphones with Mic Noise Canceling - Red

★★★★☆ (30)
$150.80
See the same product from Headphones

Stuffed Animals

NWT Squishmallows Bundle Sissy Teal Panda 14” Sager The Dog 8” Plush

NWT Squishmallows Bundle Sissy Teal Panda 14” Sager The Dog 8” Plush

★★★★☆ (20)
$29.78
Jellycat clyde capybara plush toy

Jellycat clyde capybara plush toy

★★★★☆ (5)
$50.99
Mickey and Minnie Mouse Crochet Plush

Mickey and Minnie Mouse Crochet Plush

★★★★☆ (40)
$18.00
NWT Loch Ness Monster Squishmallow Lot

NWT Loch Ness Monster Squishmallow Lot

★★★☆☆ (37)
$43.23
Pusheen Plush Bundle of 3

Pusheen Plush Bundle of 3

★★★★☆ (47)
$20.57
Rare plush

Rare plush

★★★☆☆ (22)
$136.31
See all the same products

Correction of product information

If you notice any omissions or errors in the product information on this page, please use the correction request form below.

Correction Request Form

Product Review

You must be logged in to post a review